I am blogging the start of what could turn out to be quite an interesting exchange between me and the Head of Maths here at Ballard. I will preface this by saying that I have a lot of respect for Will - just in case that is not apparent!
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
Thanks, Will. Allow me to tackle your email point-by-point:
If 6th forms decided to make it compulsory then so be it. > The latest thought is that students will need a language to access Higher Ed / get extra points towards Higher Ed for studying a range of subjects to include Eng, Ma, Sci, 1 Humanity and 1 MFL... http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/educationnews/7982716/English-Baccalaureate-to-combat-drop-in-academic-GCSEs.html
As yet, I haven't heard an argument that makes me think it is imperative that we keep languages as compulsory. > Don’t get me started! I will happily provide you with 700! www.llas.ac.uk/700reasons
I'm far from against languages and I agree that linguistic skills open many doors but I feel perhaps more often socially than professionally. > Try this article written by the (multilingual) German Ambassador to London: http://www.kwintessential.co.uk/cultural-services/articles/learn-language.html
Unless pupils are going on to study at degree level. > Or, if I get my way, we bin the National Curriculum, which is not fit for purpose, and start again with a range of qualifications designed to fit with (a) our pupils’ needs and (b) the future
Apart from that, I totally agree with you... ;-)
Thanks for responding. I would rather have 100 people arguing with me than 0 responses from gripers who don’t stand up for what they think.
Alex
-----Original Message-----
From: Will Shaylor [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: 15 November 2010 21:06
To: Alex Bellars
Subject: RE: Tweet forwarded by @bellaale
Hi Alex,
Thanks for the demo of edmodo this afternoon - it looked pretty good. Not sure I'll get round to using it though unless it takes the place of sharepoint - or can be used effectively in conjunction with sharepoint. I've spent a fair bit of time sprucing up the sharepoint site and feel I can use it pretty effectively to share things with pupils - although currently they still can't access it from home! I can see the advantages of edmodo but I also feel it's another pull into the on line social interaction world - one which I'm not sure that I necessarily want to encourage.
Thanks also for your link to the tweets last month. I did start writing a response but decided not to send it but it's been sitting in my drafts box and I'm doing a clear out so here you go! :o)
If 6th forms decided to make it compulsory then so be it. But as yet, I haven't heard an argument that makes me think it is imperative that we keep languages as compulsory. I'm far from against languages and I agree that linguistic skills open many doors but I feel perhaps more often socially than professionally. Unless pupils are going on to study at degree level.
I know - I sound like a right miserable git! :o)
See you in the morning,
Will
________________________________________
From: Alex Bellars [[email protected]]
Sent: 21 October 2010 08:53
To: Will Shaylor
Cc: Alex Bellars
Subject: Tweet forwarded by @bellaale
blagona: No language GCSE means no sixth-form place, say top schools - Education News, Education - The Inde.. http://ind.pn/9vY24l
Original Tweet: http://twitter.com/blagona/statuses/27075208237
Sent via TweetDeck (www.tweetdeck.com)